Stone-clad two-story home with dark double entry doors, a deep lawn and a diagonal limestone approach in clear afternoon light.

Stanislaus County Electric Rates: MID, TID and PG&E Compared

In June 2025, Oakdale city staff put a figure on a question most buyers never think to ask. Their report estimated that a residential customer on PG&E pays an average of $5,046 a year for electricity. A residential customer on Modesto Irrigation District pays $1,962. That gap is more than $3,000 a year. Both kinds of customers live inside the same city.

Those are 2025 estimates from a city making its case for change, and PG&E's prices have been restructured since. What still holds in October 2026 is the setup behind them. Across Stanislaus County, the company that powers a house depends on old district boundaries, and city limits don't decide it. You won't see it on the listing sheet, but it shows up on every bill after closing.

Oakdale shows the line can run through one town

The Modesto Bee reported in May 2025 that about 7,000 Oakdale homes, the vast majority, have PG&E hookups. Some newer subdivisions are on MID, a result of an effort around 2000 to bring competition to the California grid. The city's June 2025 staff report names two of those MID areas, Bridle Ridge and the Vineyards.

Turlock Irrigation District shows the same pattern further south. TID's 2026 draft hazard mitigation plan lists Turlock, Ceres, Hughson and Patterson in its electric service area, along with parts of Modesto. It also lists unincorporated communities including Denair, Keyes, Hickman, La Grange and Diablo Grande. So a Modesto address alone doesn't tell you whether a home is on MID or TID. An Oakdale address doesn't tell you whether it's on MID or PG&E.

Stanislaus LAFCO's review of MID includes a separate map titled "Modesto Irrigation District Electrical Service Area." That map is distinct from the district's irrigation sphere of influence, so the water boundary and the power boundary are two different lines. The review was adopted in 2022, so treat the map as a reference and confirm current service with the utility.

Three rate books, built three different ways

The gap goes beyond one provider charging more per kilowatt-hour. Each utility splits its charges between a fixed monthly fee and usage, sets its own tier breakpoints and defines "summer" on its own calendar.

MID Schedule D TID Schedule DE, 2026 PG&E E-1, current sheet
Fixed monthly charge $32.00 $26.00 Base Services Charge of about $6, $12 or $24.15, set by income tier
Lower usage tier 500 kWh 700 kWh Baseline allowance, which varies
Price range per kWh $0.15279 to $0.21349 $0.1338 to $0.1891 $0.32561 to $0.40702
Summer pricing applies May to September June to November bills Not seasonal on E-1; E-TOU-C summer is June 1 to September 30

The MID figures come from its posted Residential Schedule D. TID's come from the 2026 column of its DE tariff. That tariff also defines winter billing as the December through May bills and summer as the June through November bills. PG&E's come from its E-1 tariff sheet effective June 1, 2026. That sheet lists the Base Services Charge as a daily rate of $0.19713, $0.39688 or $0.79343 per income tier. The CPUC's announcement of the new structure gave the monthly amounts as $24.15 for most customers, $6 for CARE customers and $12 for FERA customers or qualifying affordable-housing residents.

The calendars matter right now. On MID, October already falls in the winter season. On TID, the October and November bills are still priced as summer months. Seller-provided bills for "last fall" mean different things depending on who sent them.

Each district also adds small per-kWh adjustments. MID currently lists a $0.0028 Capital Infrastructure Adjustment and a $0.0120 Environmental Energy Adjustment, and its Power Cost Adjustment is at $0.00000. TID has applied a $0.005 per-kWh Power Supply Adjustment credit since June 1, 2026, and adds a public-benefits charge of 2.85% of the amount billed.

The same 1,000 kWh summer month, three ways

A typical Central Valley summer month with air conditioning running shows how these structures play out. The figures below use 1,000 kWh in a summer billing month on each utility's standard residential schedule, before taxes. They assume the full $24.15-tier PG&E charge, which works out to about $23.80 over a 30-day bill.

  1. MID: $32.00 fixed, plus 500 kWh at $0.17759, plus 500 kWh at $0.21349, plus $14.80 in CIA and EEA adjustments. That comes to about $242.
  2. TID, 2026 rates: $26.00 fixed, plus 700 kWh at $0.1410, plus 300 kWh at $0.1719, less the $5.00 PSA credit. That comes to about $171, before the 2.85% public-benefits charge.
  3. PG&E E-1: Somewhere between about $349 and $431. The low end assumes every kWh is billed at the Tier 1 baseline price and the high end assumes every kWh is billed at Tier 2. A real bill lands in between, depending on the home's baseline territory, season and heating type.

Two things come out of that math. The irrigation districts are close to each other, and TID came out lower than MID at this usage level. PG&E sits in a different bracket entirely, because its per-kWh prices are roughly double the districts' and the gap grows with every extra kilowatt-hour. A larger home, a pool pump or a long July heat wave widens the spread.

PG&E's time-of-use plan follows the same pattern. Its E-TOU-C tariff lists summer prices of $0.52240 at peak and $0.39940 off-peak, with peak running 4 to 9 p.m. every day. That peak window overlaps the hours when Valley homes are working hardest to cool down.

The rates are moving in opposite directions

Comparing utilities with last year's bills misses where prices are heading.

TID's board adopted a three-year rate update at its November 26, 2024 public hearing. The update raises residential DE rates 5.6% in 2025, 5.6% in 2026 and 5.5% in 2027. The Modesto Bee's coverage put the compounded increase at 17.6%. The 2027 column is already published: a $30 customer charge and summer tiers of $0.1463, $0.1783 and $0.1962.

PG&E has gone the other way. The company announced, as Gold Rush Cam reported, that residential electric rates for bundled customers dropped about 5% on January 1, 2026, with typical bills down about $7 a month. On March 1, 2026, its standard plans switched to the new structure, adding the fixed Base Services Charge and lowering per-kWh prices. PG&E has also said it doesn't expect rates tied to its 2027–2030 General Rate Case to change before January 2027 at the earliest.

MID's posted schedule is labeled effective January 1, 2025, and no 2026 or 2027 residential base-rate change turned up in research. MID also states that the tariffs on file with its Board Secretary are the rates that apply.

The gap is narrowing from both sides. Even so, the 1,000 kWh example shows how far apart the two systems still are in 2026.

Oakdale's attempt to move the line is still open

Oakdale's council decided the gap was big enough to study. On June 2, 2025, it voted 5-0 to hire Bell Burnett & Associates for a $75,000 high-level feasibility study of joining MID, as both the Modesto Bee and the Oakdale Leader reported. The staff report listed the options to be studied: facilitation, partial service, Community Choice Aggregation or full service. The Oakdale Leader reported that MID-required system impact and facilities studies would add to the cost.

The hurdles are serious. The Bee reported that a switch would need approval from the MID board, Stanislaus LAFCO and the CPUC, and could mean years of legal wrangling. It also reported that Oakdale might have to reimburse PG&E for lines and substations, and that PG&E said its system was not for sale.

As of the council agenda for October 5, 2026, no study results or follow-up item had appeared. For a buyer looking at Oakdale today, the provider a house has is the provider to plan around.

Where this enters a purchase

None of these questions are on a standard disclosure form, so the buyer has to ask them:

  • Who serves the meter? Ask the seller for a recent bill showing the utility name, and check the address against MID's or TID's service area.
  • Which months are the bills from? Summer bills, and TID's October and November bills, show the high end of costs.
  • Which rate plan is the home on? PG&E's E-1 tiers and E-TOU-C peak hours produce very different summer bills for the same usage.
  • What are next year's rates? TID's 2027 rates are already published. PG&E has said its General Rate Case won't move rates before January 2027 at the earliest.

A few direct questions

Can a homeowner switch from PG&E to MID or TID? Service follows the territory a property sits in. The Oakdale effort shows that changing a boundary takes approvals from several agencies and can take years.

Does PG&E's Base Services Charge apply to every customer? It applies to customers on standard plans such as E-1 and E-TOU-C. The amount depends on the income tier the customer is assigned to.

Are MID and TID rates identical? No. TID's fixed charge is lower, its usage tiers are wider and its summer season runs later.

Comparing two Stanislaus County homes in Oakdale, Modesto or Turlock, and want the utility question answered before you write an offer? Lori Cabral can pull the service provider and seasonal bill history into your comparison, along with price and condition. Start with a free Home Market Analysis.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Work With Lori Ann

Contact Lori Ann today to learn more about her unique approach to real estate and how she can help you get the results you deserve.

Follow Me on Instagram